Abby's Guide to Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more)
Username Password
Discussions Reviews More Guides
Abby’s Guide > Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) > Discussions > Husqvarna Track Drive Snowblower--How Good?

Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) Discussions

Search For:
epremack


Joined: Feb 24, 2011
Points: 8

Husqvarna Track Drive Snowblower--How Good?
Original Message   Aug 26, 2011 11:19 am
I've been planning to buy a Honda snowblower this fall from my local dealer.  Had my eyes on the 928TA model which I've used in the past and have found quite good. 

He said he's going to start carrying Husqvarna too, noting that its 1830EXLT model has track drive, hydrostatic transmission, and an 18 lb-ft motor (Snow King), and is a lot cheaper than the Honda. 

He also noted that Honda has upgraded the motor for its 30-inch blower to its GX 390, but tells me this one is much harder to handle than the 928.

Anyone familiar with this Husky or the upgraded Honda? 

I need to be able to reliably blow out a steep, 100-foot drive.  Where I live, we measure our wet,  heavy snow ("Sierra Cement") by the foot, not the inch.
Replies: 18 - 23 of 23Next page of topicsPreviousAllView as Outline
Whoha


Location: Minneapolis
Joined: Nov 5, 2011
Points: 35

Re: Husqvarna Track Drive Snowblower--How Good?
Reply #18   Aug 25, 2012 10:11 pm
Snowmann wrote:
http://m.powerequipment.honda.com/pdf/manuals/00X317677230.pdf

There are 2 sections that refer to it in this manual. There would be no reason to offer Honda branded hydrostatic oil if there were no service requirements. Honda hydrostatic oil is 5W-30 petrolium based motor oil (Husqvarna's is too). I would imagine it is possible, even likely in some areas, that you could go the life of the unit with original equipment oil. There are duty cycles however whereas this may not happen.

The Ariens unit is completely self contained with a diaphragm bladder expansion tank. The 0W-40 synthetic hydrostatic oil in the Ariens will not deteriorate with an extreme duty cycle or higher ambient temperature hence there are no service requirements. Note also the oil in the Ariens is not the low grade hydrocracked petrolium oil which is what 99% of the "synthetic" labeled oils are at your local auto parts retailer. These types of oils work as well as a true synthetic but not to the same degree of longevity. If you do change out or fill the oil in your Honda I would recommend the same.


Snowman, Where did you find out the hydro oil in a newer  Honda 928 is 5w30 motor oil and the Husky is 0w40? I know Honda can go cheap, I own a Honda Odyessy  and it uses the Acura TL car tranny and it has major issues. The only way to save it flush out Honda trans oil three times with Redline synthetic because of no oil pan. That gives you 89%  or what ever of new Redline. I can see Honda going cheap on the oil. There is more to this story, but I won't get into it here.

So, why don't they use true tranny fluid? Can you state where you found this out, so if valid I will change over to Redline 0w 40 in my Honda 928 this year.  Please be long winded, the more info I can get the better.



An  off comment to this thread. I had a 828 Yamaha wheel that would plan and simple kill my 2011 928 Honda. The Honda seems to be a mid frame snowblower and the Yamaha was a large frame. The 8 hp motor on the Yamaha seems like a 11hp when comparing my Honda 928. My 20 year old Yamaha is greatly missed. The Honda was my only other choice in USA. I would of went with a Yamaha, but $3000+, no wheel version  and Canada only was not in the cards for me. I would kill for the larger heavier motor that the 1130 received.

.
This message was modified Aug 25, 2012 by Whoha
Whoha


Location: Minneapolis
Joined: Nov 5, 2011
Points: 35

Re: Husqvarna Track Drive Snowblower--How Good?
Reply #19   Aug 26, 2012 9:40 am
Added note ,I think I will wait till my warranty is up in 2 years till I make the move. But again, fill me in on the oil spec info.
This message was modified Aug 26, 2012 by Whoha
Snowmann


Joined: Dec 3, 2003
Points: 494

Re: Husqvarna Track Drive Snowblower--How Good?
Reply #20   Aug 31, 2012 10:29 pm
Whoha wrote:
Snowman, Where did you find out the hydro oil in a newer  Honda 928 is 5w30 motor oil and the Husky is 0w40? I know Honda can go cheap, I own a Honda Odyessy  and it uses the Acura TL car tranny and it has major issues. The only way to save it flush out Honda trans oil three times with Redline synthetic because of no oil pan. That gives you 89%  or what ever of new Redline. I can see Honda going cheap on the oil. There is more to this story, but I won't get into it here.

So, why don't they use true tranny fluid? Can you state where you found this out, so if valid I will change over to Redline 0w 40 in my Honda 928 this year.  Please be long winded, the more info I can get the better.



An  off comment to this thread. I had a 828 Yamaha wheel that would plan and simple kill my 2011 928 Honda. The Honda seems to be a mid frame snowblower and the Yamaha was a large frame. The 8 hp motor on the Yamaha seems like a 11hp when comparing my Honda 928. My 20 year old Yamaha is greatly missed. The Honda was my only other choice in USA. I would of went with a Yamaha, but $3000+, no wheel version  and Canada only was not in the cards for me. I would kill for the larger heavier motor that the 1130 received.

.


Both Honda and Husqvarna are 5W-30 Petrolium oil. 0W-40 synthetic oil will run ~10 degrees cooler (versus 5W-30 dino oil), have an operational ceiling temperature about 50-75 degress higher, it will have more stable operational characteristics at a broader range of operating temperatures (shorter warm up stall time at very low temps), and will not pass through the seal interface as readily due to its homogenous nature (no lighter constituent oils). Again, get real synthetic for longevity, not hydrocracked synthetic. Mobil 1 0W-40 European Car Formula is available at the Wal-Mart around here which is the real deal. This is what I would run in any hydrostatic snowblower transmission. Even more important would be use of synthetic gear oil in the auger gear cases. The Ariens L3 stuff is top shelf. It's a proprietary synthetic 75W-140 GL5 MT1 with a special EP formulation. I'd use this in the Honda too for many of the same reasons. The mis-matched gear set in the Honda (worm on helical) is hard on oil due to point contact. The film strength of the L3 oil will protect much better against metal on metal contact/pitting. Again, the oils that Honda uses probably work fine in most cases, but you can do better if the machine sees a very high duty cycle. The better lubricants will extend the life of the machine under those circumstances.

BTW, ATF transmission fluid is not suitable for use with Hydrostatic transmissions similar to the ones being discussed. As such, do not use. The viscosity characteristics are not compatible.

Whoha


Location: Minneapolis
Joined: Nov 5, 2011
Points: 35

Re: Husqvarna Track Drive Snowblower--How Good?
Reply #21   Sep 2, 2012 9:26 am
Snowmann wrote:
Both Honda and Husqvarna are 5W-30 Petrolium oil. 0W-40 synthetic oil will run ~10 degrees cooler (versus 5W-30 dino oil), have an operational ceiling temperature about 50-75 degress higher, it will have more stable operational characteristics at a broader range of operating temperatures (shorter warm up stall time at very low temps), and will not pass through the seal interface as readily due to its homogenous nature (no lighter constituent oils). Again, get real synthetic for longevity, not hydrocracked synthetic. Mobil 1 0W-40 European Car Formula is available at the Wal-Mart around here which is the real deal. This is what I would run in any hydrostatic snowblower transmission. Even more important would be use of synthetic gear oil in the auger gear cases. The Ariens L3 stuff is top shelf. It's a proprietary synthetic 75W-140 GL5 MT1 with a special EP formulation. I'd use this in the Honda too for many of the same reasons. The mis-matched gear set in the Honda (worm on helical) is hard on oil due to point contact. The film strength of the L3 oil will protect much better against metal on metal contact/pitting. Again, the oils that Honda uses probably work fine in most cases, but you can do better if the machine sees a very high duty cycle. The better lubricants will extend the life of the machine under those circumstances.

BTW, ATF transmission fluid is not suitable for use with Hydrostatic transmissions similar to the ones being discussed. As such, do not use. The viscosity characteristics are not compatible.


Where did you find this out?  I just can't take your word and possibly wreak my machine by some guy on a forum I have no clue who or what he does and if his info is correct. Can you please give me more info on were and how you found this out?
mikiewest


Joined: Dec 29, 2007
Points: 262

Re: Husqvarna Track Drive Snowblower--How Good?
Reply #22   Sep 4, 2012 9:01 pm
Anyone know what the Ariens w/hydro are going for?
This message was modified Sep 4, 2012 by mikiewest
aa335


Joined: Nov 29, 2008
Points: 2434

Re: Husqvarna Track Drive Snowblower--How Good?
Reply #23   Sep 16, 2012 12:14 am
Snowmann wrote:
This model (and others) are now on the Ariens website. Note there are wheel drive and track drive models.

Regarding your comment about temperature; even in a cold ambient environment hydrostatic transmissions can run very hot. They are well under 50% efficient (as low as 25-30% for certain models). The smaller hydrostatic transmissions can emit more the 1000W in heat. The small surface area of the pump housings have a hard time purging the heat. The Honda (928TAS in particular) has a loaded hydrostatic oil temperature of around 200 degrees F (in a +32F ambient temperature). That is approximately 25 degrees below the temperature at which petrolium oil starts to break down and deteriorate. Honda uses conventional petrolium oil for this application. The Ariens (equivalent Hydro Pro 28 Track) loaded hydrostatic oil temperature runs ~50F cooler and uses synthetic oil which will reliably operate in conditions over 50F higher than petrolium oil. This is why there is a service schedule for the hydrostatic oil in the Honda and not the Ariens. All said, the Ariens can take more drive load at higher ambient temperatures without risk to the longevity of the drive.


I recently checked Ariens website, these products actually exists.  :)  Although I prefer Ariens wheeled models, tracked models are an afterthought bolt on and not designed from the beginning.  I will make a point of checking these new models out in the next coming months.

I haven't had any issues with my Honda hydrostatic and my homeowner use has not stressed my snowblower to the point of self destruction.   It is nice to know that Ariens has gone the extra mile by making their new products robust for commercial use.
Replies: 18 - 23 of 23Next page of topicsPreviousAllView as Outline
Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) Guide   •   Discussions  Reviews  
AbbysGuide.com   About Us   Terms of Use   Privacy Policy   Contact Us
Copyright 1998-2021 AbbysGuide.com. All rights reserved.
Site by Take 42