Abby's Guide to Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more)
Username Password
Discussions Reviews More Guides
Abby’s Guide > Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) > Discussions > Briggs & Stratton Engine HP Disclaimer

Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) Discussions

Search For:
Richie


Bring On The White Stuff

Location: Long Island, New York
Joined: Dec 12, 2003
Points: 562

Briggs & Stratton Engine HP Disclaimer
Original Message   Feb 16, 2005 12:40 pm

At least Briggs has all this in writing on their website it you know enough to look for it.  Obviously Tecumseh and any other engine manufacturer follows this same rating procedure.  Pretty lousy numbers when you think about gross HP as opposed to BHP that we are really concerned with.  Still, they don't mention if this rating system takes into account the very lean EPA carburetors, so I'd have to say no, which means its even worse.  If you look at the last paragraph that I highlighted in RED, this supposedly 8 hp engine I have that is run in ACTUAL conditions and NOT in optimum laboratory conditions, has a pitiful rating, as do all of our engines.

Horsepower Ratings

The power ratings shown with the individual engine series on the preceding pages are established in accordance with SAE (Society of Automotive Engineers) code J1940 (Small Engine Power & Torque Rating Procedure) (Proposed Revision 2001-09). Power curve and engine performance data are obtained in accordance with SAE J1349 (Net) or J1995 (Gross) Engine Power Test Codes.

In accordance with SAE J1349 (Net) or J1995 (Gross) Engine Power Test Codes, power curves are developed from laboratory test engines and are corrected to standard conditions which are:

Altitude: 100 meters (328 ft)
Ambient Temperature: 77 F (25 C)

If the engine will be operated under ambient conditions different from above standard conditions, the following factors should be accounted for in estimating "on site" power output:

Engine power will decrease 3.5% for each 1000 ft (300 m) above sea level and 1% for each 10 F (5.6 C) above standard temperature of 60 F (15.6 C).

The actual "on site" power output will also vary depending on other factors including the manner in which the engine is operated, the fuel that is used, and the application in which it is installed.

The "Maximum BHP" curve represents maximum performance output of optimum laboratory test engines of a particular model. A statistical mean of production engines, with 95% confidence, will develop no less than 85% of the Maximum BHP when tested after run-in to reduce friction and after clean-out of combustion chamber, with valves, carburetor and ignition systems adjusted to laboratory standards.

The "Recommended Maximum Operating BHP" is a calculated curve and represents 85% of the maximum BHP curve. For practical operation, BHP load and speed should be within the limits shown in the "Recommended Maximum Operating BHP" curve.

If the maximum speed of the engine specified for a given application is governed to a speed less than the speed at which the Maximum BHP occurs, the engine will not achieve the Maximum BHP in that application. For applications requiring operation at other than the recommended engine speeds, complete details of the proposed engine installation should be referred to the factory for evaluation.

Source:  Briggs & Stratton Technical/Warranty
http://www.commercialpower.com/display/router.asp?DOCID=76491

This message was modified Feb 16, 2005 by Richie


Richie
Replies: 1 - 10 of 23NextNext page of topicsAllView as Outline
Ben07


The more you know about something, the more you find there is to know.

Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Joined: Feb 26, 2004
Points: 178

Re: Briggs & Stratton Engine HP Disclaimer
Reply #1   Feb 16, 2005 2:25 pm
Richie wrote:

If the maximum speed of the engine specified for a given application is governed to a speed less than the speed at which the Maximum BHP occurs, the engine will not achieve the Maximum BHP in that application. Source:  Briggs & Stratton Technical/Warranty
http://www.commercialpower.com/display/router.asp?DOCID=76491



Exactly what you been sayin Richie. Thus my thoughts as to when you are able to find the charts within operating range for it's application,Like for a snowblower.  3600RPM 8HP  then there is a 9 HP engine, no graphs same engine, etc But 9HP?

Did they just take it from the lab test's at a higher RPM.  All I can say is we haven't been able to find proof that they didn't.

All we can know for sure is they sure charge you more. no not just the motor, they gift wrap it into a little more glossier machine, where they increase to price for a percentage of the additional horsepower that you are not getting as both run at the same operating range.  Remember this all started for me after few years of repairing other peoples machines.  No big deal, moved to diff area word got around, now everybody that needs repairs is your best friend. yada yada. Only reason I mentioned that is that is how I was lucky enough to test out different types and horses, and torques of diff machines.  Cause I usually don't refuse a Snowblower,  more money to be made, and I like them.  When peoples lawnmowers etc break, they are more relaxed etcThey have time and is easier to borrow etc  and they can buy 89 dollar special.  When SB breaks, Oh my gawd a catastrophy, how am i gonna get out to road for work and a low end new one min 600 bucks.   I haven't ben able to do a side by side comparison say from an 8 and an11 or similar,  But it is my opinion if they are similar engines in bore an stroke and strength/size, runnin like just on crank pulley etc, you got always take the whole machine into consideration there ain't that much difference under the same type load. If there is any difference at all.   An that s the only way you can test em l either a dyno or a seat of the pants practical application.

Ben07

 

 

 

Ariens 8524LE, Toro CCR2000, Jacobsen S-B S-blowers, Generac 10hp Gen-convt. to N.G., 5 L-boys(D's F's &Dura( 74,77,80,88,00), Antiq. 1960 AYP 20 in. mag w 3.5 Tech mower. Ryan/Ryobi gas Trim. AYP 205 gas blwr. Mac c-saw,Toro E-blwr, 2 Weed-E e. stg. trims. outboards, boats, util trail, 2 Jeeps 
MountainMan


Overpowered is Usually Adequate


Location: Connecticut
Joined: Feb 19, 2003
Points: 1564

Re: Briggs & Stratton Engine HP Disclaimer
Reply #2   Feb 16, 2005 3:14 pm
That part about Power loss at Elevation, Ive been preaching that for YEARS. Especially for our Higher up Western Customers. They are lucky to get Half the rated hoarsepower to the snow when you figure in Elevation, Temp, Driveline losses and Good Old wear and tear.

Bigger is almost always  BETTER.

Ariens 1128PRO- Honda Generator_ Husky 480-257 Jonsered 2050Turbo- Shindiawa T2500 SCAG Mower -little wonder blower-Sears track blower-Coleman Generator- Bombadier ATV-Stihl HS-45 Etc-Etc-Etc
Richie


Bring On The White Stuff

Location: Long Island, New York
Joined: Dec 12, 2003
Points: 562

Re: Briggs & Stratton Engine HP Disclaimer
Reply #3   Feb 16, 2005 4:16 pm
Thanks Ben.

Any way you look at it, no matter what size engine you buy, as long as the manufacturers are allowed to rate the engines in this way, you most certainly should forget whatever HP rating they give it.  I can only say that I am very happy I didn't spend the extra $400.00 for the 11 HP OHV engine for my model. 

This message was modified Feb 16, 2005 by Richie


Richie
MountainMan


Overpowered is Usually Adequate


Location: Connecticut
Joined: Feb 19, 2003
Points: 1564

Re: Briggs & Stratton Engine HP Disclaimer
Reply #4   Feb 16, 2005 4:32 pm
Richie wrote:


And you were saying ?

Ariens 1128PRO- Honda Generator_ Husky 480-257 Jonsered 2050Turbo- Shindiawa T2500 SCAG Mower -little wonder blower-Sears track blower-Coleman Generator- Bombadier ATV-Stihl HS-45 Etc-Etc-Etc
Richie


Bring On The White Stuff

Location: Long Island, New York
Joined: Dec 12, 2003
Points: 562

Re: Briggs & Stratton Engine HP Disclaimer
Reply #5   Feb 16, 2005 4:36 pm
Hi Mountain,

I posted something in the wrong place, but I just fixed it.  I also do recall you mentioning the altitude issue somewhere.  Altitude really makes for some horrible numbers. 

Richie
Ben07


The more you know about something, the more you find there is to know.

Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Joined: Feb 26, 2004
Points: 178

Re: Briggs & Stratton Engine HP Disclaimer
Reply #6   Feb 16, 2005 5:26 pm
No problem Richie, I believe you got another Bullseye on that briggs post, Right over the first Bullseye on the Lawnboy disclaimer.  Shootin one Bullseye thru another, where I come from is called "shootin Tacks".  Tacks are sharp.

Ben

Ariens 8524LE, Toro CCR2000, Jacobsen S-B S-blowers, Generac 10hp Gen-convt. to N.G., 5 L-boys(D's F's &Dura( 74,77,80,88,00), Antiq. 1960 AYP 20 in. mag w 3.5 Tech mower. Ryan/Ryobi gas Trim. AYP 205 gas blwr. Mac c-saw,Toro E-blwr, 2 Weed-E e. stg. trims. outboards, boats, util trail, 2 Jeeps 
snowshoveler


tides in dirts out surfs up

Location: bridgewater nova scotia...aka the swamp
Joined: Jan 3, 2003
Points: 1261

Re: Briggs & Stratton Engine HP Disclaimer
Reply #7   Feb 16, 2005 5:42 pm
youn will loose some ponies with altitude yes .

but you will also notice horsepower numbers are taken at 60 degrees...not much need for a snowblower then.

at realistic temp you will actually be making up for some lost power...when its cold the air is denser and you get a better burn.

the engines are also rated with all there emmisions carbs and if muffler has a calalyst in it then it must be installed.

most engines are tested without a muffler...or with a stack.

any questions.

later chris

craftsman 10/28 snowblower with tracks   husky 372xpg chainsaw   sachs dolmar bc212 bushsaw   mondo trimmer   monster tractor with trailer    cheep wheelbarro and couple shovels and a partridge in a pear tree 
Richie


Bring On The White Stuff

Location: Long Island, New York
Joined: Dec 12, 2003
Points: 562

Re: Briggs & Stratton Engine HP Disclaimer
Reply #8   Feb 16, 2005 8:02 pm
snowshoveler wrote:

the engines are also rated with all there emmisions carbs and if muffler has a calalyst in it then it must be installed.

most engines are tested without a muffler...or with a stack.


Hi Chris,

For the first time in over two years I've known you on Abby's I have to disagree with you   With the pain staking research I've done in the last few weeks, I've come to realize one thing with these engine manufacturers; don't take anything for granted with them.  Unless I actually see an engine performance chart stating in the fine print that those charts reflect the emission carburetors, I just can't swallow it.  I don't recall if you saw another disclaimer on one of the other threads I posted on, but just in case, look below at one of LawnBoy's 6.5 HP walk behind mowers.

* This engine was manufactured and laboratory rated by the Tecumseh Power Company at 6.5 gross horsepower in accordance with SAE J1940. As configured to meet safety, emission, and operating requirements, the actual horsepower on this class of lawn mower will be significantly lower.

Chris, they are not simply saying slightly less here, they are saying significantly lower.  This is strictly my opinion here, but significantly to me means something in the neighborhood of actual HP being 3-3 1/2.  So why wouldn't my 8 hp Tecumseh be rated similarly since all these engines are rated exactly the same way? 

BTW...Chris, I hope this doesn't mean you're going to fire me for not agreeing on one point



Richie
MissSnowshoveler


If you don't have free speech, what do you have?

Location: NS
Joined: Feb 5, 2005
Points: 706

Re: Briggs & Stratton Engine HP Disclaimer
Reply #9   Feb 16, 2005 8:22 pm

BTW...Chris, I hope this doesn't mean you're going to fire me for not agreeing on one point

Well believe me, if the Boss fired everyone for disagreeing with him, I'd be out of a job along, long time ago...

You should see the bench he's designated for you.  It'll take you months just to find it under all the junk - no that's not the right word - crap - no, trash - no...well you get my point.

There's a power saw sitting there from 1950 and a 36 volt generator - so your work is all ready cut out for ya - when shall we expect you to be arriving?

Sherri

If you don't have free speech, what do you have?
Richie


Bring On The White Stuff

Location: Long Island, New York
Joined: Dec 12, 2003
Points: 562

Re: Briggs & Stratton Engine HP Disclaimer
Reply #10   Feb 16, 2005 8:39 pm
MissSnowshoveler wrote:
Well believe me, if the Boss fired everyone for disagreeing with him, I'd be out of a job along, long time ago...


Hey Sherri,

That's good to know, thanks.  Hey, I love working on the old stuff, I'll get that Saw and Generator working in no time.

BTW...I'm actually buried under all that stuff.  The other day, while kneeling down trying to clean the place up, someone rolled a big heavy snowblower over my back and pinned me there.  I wish someone would come and help me, the tire chains are still digging into the back of my head

Richie
Replies: 1 - 10 of 23NextNext page of topicsAllView as Outline
Outdoor Power Equipment (Lawn Mowers, Snow Blowers, Chain Saws and more) Guide   •   Discussions  Reviews  
AbbysGuide.com   About Us   Terms of Use   Privacy Policy   Contact Us
Copyright 1998-2024 AbbysGuide.com. All rights reserved.
Site by Take 42